Культурная аппроприация — когда доминирующая группа берёт элементы культуры угнетённой группы без согласия или понимания. Спор о границах — один из главных культурных boyout 2010-20-х.
Определение
- Edwards, 1981 — academic term
- "Cultural appreciation" vs "appropriation"
- Power dynamics central
- Intent matters less чем impact
Примеры
- White хипстеры dreadlocks
- Halloween costumes racial
- Native American headdresses at festivals
- Chinese qipao на prom
- Japanese yukata поверхностно
Controversy
- Some say: it's just culture
- Others: it's theft + disrespect
- Power dynamics key
- Complex debates
Fashion industry
- Louis Vuitton Native designs
- Victoria's Secret feather headdress
- Gucci turbans
- Responses vary
Music
- Elvis "stole" black music
- Miley Cyrus "We Can't Stop" (2013)
- K-pop blackness aesthetics
- White rappers debates
Food
- "Ethnic" restaurants white-owned
- Taco trucks by non-Mexicans
- "Clean" versions of ethnic
- Recipe ownership
Yoga
- Hindu spirituality → fitness
- Millions practice
- Often divorced from roots
- Swami Vivekananda irony
Cornrows
- African origin
- Kim Kardashian "boxer braids"
- Criticism fell hard
- Apologies follow
Appreciation vs appropriation
- Respect roots
- Ask permission
- Credit source
- Deep understanding
Russian context
- Matryoshka dolls глобальные
- Ushanka, vodka внедрены
- Russians: less protected minority
- Historical tensions with neighbors
Soviet "brotherhood of peoples"
- Forced integration
- Cultural sharing (officially)
- Underlying Russification
- Post-Soviet reckoning
Indigenous peoples
- Native American concerns specifically
- Sacred objects
- Traditional Ecological Knowledge
- Patents on indigenous plants
Biopiracy
- Pharmaceutical companies
- Patenting indigenous medicines
- Neem, turmeric case в India
- Courts sometimes ruling
Nagoya Protocol
- UN biodiversity treaty
- Benefit-sharing требуется
- Slow compliance
- Some progress
Museum objects
- Parthenon Marbles (Elgin)
- Benin Bronzes
- Egyptian mummies
- Repatriation debates
Repatriation
- Germany returning Benin Bronzes
- France gradually
- UK resisting
- Museum reform
Cross-cultural creativity
- Fusion cuisine: celebration or appropriation?
- Music genres blend
- Art reference other cultures
- Impossible avoid exchange
Questions to ask
- Am I invited?
- Do I understand context?
- Am I profiting from tradition?
- Would community be hurt?
- Would they be grateful?
Critics of term
- Over-polices exchange
- Oversensitivity
- Purity politics
- Neo-segregationism
Defenders
- Recognizes power
- Protects marginalized
- Encourages respect
- Education
Generational divide
- Young more concerned
- Gen X less
- Cultural shift rapid
- Intra-group disagreements
Internet amplification
- Twitter callouts
- Viral criticism
- Public shaming
- Speed of change
Business responses
- Sensitivity consultants
- Diverse teams
- Community engagement
- Mixed success
Harmful examples
- Brownface, blackface
- Holocaust costumes
- Native names for sports (Redskins)
- "Sexy" stereotypes
Successful appreciation
- Hamilton (musical) — complex debate
- Food crossovers
- Genuine collaboration
- Acknowledgment of source
Cultural commons
- Some argue all culture flows
- "Pure" cultures myth
- Always borrowed
- Focus on respect
Capitalist context
- Profit motive центральный
- Commercialization problematic
- Unequal benefits
- Underlying structure
Russia, Ukraine, vyshyvanka
- Traditional embroidered shirts
- Ukrainian cultural symbol
- Russians wearing — fraught
- Politicized fashion
Halloween
- Annual controversies
- "Mexican bandit", "Indian princess"
- Educational campaigns
- Slow change
Language
- Black English (AAVE) appropriated
- Gen Z memes from black Twitter
- Credit often missing
How to share respectfully
- Learn history
- Support community businesses
- Credit creators
- Listen к concerns
- Accept critiques
Полит backlash
- "Political correctness gone mad"
- Right-wing critiques
- "Cancel culture" framing
- Culture wars aspect
Future
- Conversations will continue
- Global culture flows
- Better models of exchange
- Nuance matters
Письма читателей
Обсуждение номера.0
Слово читателю
Хотите ответить автору? Подписка даёт право голоса.
Загрузка комментариев…